Itemize Books Supposing Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)

Original Title: Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home
ISBN: 0743452380 (ISBN13: 9780743452380)
Edition Language: English
Series: The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3
Books Free Download Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)
Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3) Paperback | Pages: 224 pages
Rating: 3.8 | 1234 Users | 94 Reviews

Particularize Containing Books Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)

Title:Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)
Author:Harry Kemelman
Book Format:Paperback
Book Edition:Special Edition
Pages:Pages: 224 pages
Published:September 1st 2002 by iBooks (first published 1969)
Categories:Mystery. Fiction. Literature. Jewish. Crime

Relation In Pursuance Of Books Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)

No, I'm sorry, this wasn't really good enough. After a promising second novel, we are back to extreeeeeemely slooooow setup (over half the novel) and then cramming all the actual events and investigation into the last 30 pages or so. Which for a book with over 200 pages is not stellar. The Rabbi, in fact, does not "stay home"--he goes away for a weekend in which the events happen, so everything he gets is second or third hand. He doesn't even do much sleuthing--he just kind of sits around. Oh, he wanders in to the police station now and then and holds forth, but that's about it.

There were many characters but none of them developed--and none of them particularly sympathetic. Two black guys (that's what they called themselves in those days), one obnoxious and the other almost invisible in terms of personality. An old codger who hardly speaks. The obligatory airheaded female. The shiksa wife (who in this case always spoke to her husband of many years as "lover" and set my teeth on edge every time). The obligatory spiritual head-case. Even the rabbi and his wife and son hardly really interact.

What we do get is over a hundred pages of--you guessed it--temple politics and chatter. Who gets to sit where, what the seats are like, do they get their nameplate or not? And more important than that--who cares and what does that have to do with anything? Not a lot. And he's still putting strange dialogue into the mouths of his characters. I really don't think that Jewish people talking to each other about their plans for their families would say things like, "You know how we Jews feel about education...blah, blah blah..." No, they'd say something like, "Everybody wants to give their kids the best chance in life," or "You know how important a degree is, if they want to do well later on..."

I've read that Kemelman wanted to write novels about Judaism and his publisher said no, no-one would be interested, he should write crime novels. Well, hey, I guess poor old Chaim Potok got it wrong, then. *sarcasm* Or maybe it was a nice way of telling him his particular elucubrations on Judaism weren't fascinating. That I could go along with.
This book would have worked a lot better if the author had managed to interleave the talktalk with a little more plot. But it is neither detective fiction, nor a real mystery. I am startled that he was given an award for his writing.

After the second novel I had higher hopes than this. After this one, I'm debating whether to bother with more of the small rabbi's smalltown concerns. *Yawn*

Rating Containing Books Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)
Ratings: 3.8 From 1234 Users | 94 Reviews

Write-Up Containing Books Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home (The Rabbi Small Mysteries #3)
The rabbi continues to use his mystery-solving skills gleaned from the study of the Talmud. A young man dies after a beach party. Was it an accident? Alcohol poisoning perhaps? Or was it tied to something and someone else? The rabbi explains his theory to Chief Lanigan who decides to use a possible witness test the rabbi's theory. The culprit responsible for the young man's death as well as a man in a different city is caught and innocent teens are cleared. Of course earlier in the book the

When the death of a pot~using and was about to be Mary Jane dealer as well as once upon a time athlete at Hillhouse where the planned break~away synagogue would have been... Rabbi David Small was yet again put in the middle of a vortex of contentious old and new council members which all boil down to egos, entitlement, recognition and the politics of being pro~current civil rights issues which have nothing at all to do with Jewish life according to the Talmud and the Rabbi. Gorfinkle's group is

These book are different, the mystery isn't given at the beginning like most book, the mystery didn't even start till about half way through. The whole first half of the book is set up. What happening in the community and getting everything in place. I am not really sure if I like it or not. I keep wanting the meat of the story but I find it interesting at the same time. It must be working for me since I will continue to read the next book in the series.

Sunny Day the Rabbi Stayed Home by Harry KemelanSeries: Yes Rabbi Small Mysteries Book #3Format: HardcoverStar 2Recommend: Yes Would Reread: MaybeThis was a looong readOver all I was really disappointed in this one and had to make myself finish it.It was boring most of the time.The book focused mainly on temple politics for the first half.Even after the murder things still did not pick up and the ending felt rushed.Sunday the Rabbi Stayed home was not as good as the first two books in the

What happens when you rearrange your TBR piles? You discover buried treasure. I was so close to the end of this book, so I polished it off. The Rabbi David Small books are mysteries, but are also treatises about the Jewish faith. We learn a lot about the life of a rabbi and the Temple and its congregants. Written in 1969, I shouldnt have been surprised that there was some racist content, but it struck a sour note. The rabbi speaks out against it, unsurprisingly, and that helps some. I didnt like

Sunday the Rabbi Stayed Home, the 3rd book containing Rabbi David Small, was written by Harry Kemelman. The synagogue of the fictional town of Barnards Crossing is in turmoil about who gets to sit near the front. Inevitably there is a murder connected with the marijuana drug black market. This cozy mystery, set in New England in the 1960s has a very good description of Jewish Law.

Maybe it's because the previous story was so good, but this one seemed very weak. Way too much temple politics, and the solution to the mystery was compressed to a few paragraphs followed by an abbreviated and very weak capture of the murderer. My least favorite Rabbi mystery so far.